Louisiana senator withdraws bill lowering drinking age - KPLC 7 News, Lake Charles, Louisiana

Louisiana senator withdraws bill lowering drinking age

Sen. Eric LaFleur, D-Ville Platte, on Tuesday withdrew his bill to let 19- and 20-year-olds drink alcohol if they obtained a state certificate. (Sarah Gamard/LSU Manship School News Service) Sen. Eric LaFleur, D-Ville Platte, on Tuesday withdrew his bill to let 19- and 20-year-olds drink alcohol if they obtained a state certificate. (Sarah Gamard/LSU Manship School News Service)

By Kaylee Poche

and Ryan Noonan

LSU Manship School News Service

Sen. Eric LaFleur on Tuesday withdrew one of the most talked about bills of the legislative session his proposal to allow 19 and 20 year-olds to drink legally-- amid fears that the state could lose federal highway funds.

LaFleur, a Democrat from Ville Platte, said he thought his bill, which would have required parental consent and alcohol education courses, would have led to more responsible drinking.

But state officials and other lawmakers said the state risked losing up to $600 million in highway construction funds under federal laws meant to encourage safer driving.

Articles detailing LaFleur’s bill garnered hundreds of shares and comments on social media, and users had mixed reactions about the proposal.

“The age of adulthood is all over the place,” Shane Purl commented on Facebook. “If a person can join the military, vote, get married, buy a home, and go to prison at or before the age of eighteen, then they should be able to drink alcohol, or just make everything 21.”

“No, no, no, we have enough issues with our youth this will only get worse,” Sharrone Monteith, another Facebook user, wrote. “Higher college drinking rate, higher sexual crimes against younger victims, higher drunk driving rate and higher car insurance...how would we be winning?”

LaFleur said he did not think the bill would have increased drinking at all and instead would have encouraged responsible drinking, citing the alcohol education courses young adults required to obtain the certificate.

“I mean, I understand their argument, I just believe that those that want to access alcohol are accessing it today, and they are doing it now,” LaFleur said. “So, I don’t think there is going to be really any increase in access. There will be a certain level of responsibility with that access that doesn’t exist today.”

Because the bill would not technically lower the drinking age, LaFleur said he did not think meeting federal highway fund requirements would be a problem.

“It doesn’t really change the law,” LaFleur said. “People think all of a sudden I’m doing something different--I’m not. The only difference really is does your mother or father have to be with you when you go to listen to a band so you can drink a beer.”

But several committee members and Juana Marine-Lombard, the Louisiana Office of Alcohol and Tobacco Control, voiced concerns over whether the federal government would pull those funds.

“ATC, as far as federal funding, is just the tip of the iceberg,” Marine-Lombard said. “State police receive way more money in the highway safety grant, and Department of Transportation has something like $600 million to lose. When we’re sitting on a fiscal cliff and you’re talking about risking millions over this, where does the money come from to fund DOT, ATC and state police?”

LaFleur said, however, that his bill contained a provision that would have nullified the plan to let 19 and 20 year-olds drink legally if it resulted in the Department of Transportation losing its federal highway dollars. Similar amendments could have been made for other departments, LaFleur said.

Paula Zachary, a volunteer for Mothers Against Drunk Driving whose 19-year-old son died from drunk driving, was prepared to testify against LaFleur’s bill before it was withdrawn.

“I actually talked to him, and I asked him not to bring the bill back up,” Zachary said. “It’s going to eventually say, ‘Okay, if 19 year-old can do this, why not 17 and 18 year-olds?’ It’s going to gradually go on a downslide.”

“As a parent and a part of Louisiana, it is super dangerous,” she added. “We’ve got to save our kids. We’ve got to do whatever we can.”

LaFleur said he would continue to work on the bill and will likely propose it again next year.

“Change like this sometimes takes a little while,” LaFleur said.

Copyright KPLC 2018. All rights reserved.

  • More Local NewsNewsMore>>

  • Race across the lake: sixth annual Dragon Boat Race coming to Lake Charles

    Race across the lake: sixth annual Dragon Boat Race coming to Lake Charles

    Saturday, April 21 2018 7:24 PM EDT2018-04-21 23:24:40 GMT
    Dragon Boat Race (Source: KPLC)Dragon Boat Race (Source: KPLC)

    The CHRISTUS St. Patrick Foundation will host their sixth annual Dragon Boat Races at 9 a.m. Saturday, April 28 at the Lake Charles Civic Center Seawall. The event benefits Children's Miracle Network.  In this year’s race, up to 30 teams will race across the lake, competing to be the 2018 Dragon Boat Race winning team. Each team consists of 20 members who paddle a 41-foot vessel to the beat of their team drummer. In our 30-minute special report Race Across...

    More >>

    The CHRISTUS St. Patrick Foundation will host their sixth annual Dragon Boat Races at 9 a.m. Saturday, April 28 at the Lake Charles Civic Center Seawall. The event benefits Children's Miracle Network.  In this year’s race, up to 30 teams will race across the lake, competing to be the 2018 Dragon Boat Race winning team. Each team consists of 20 members who paddle a 41-foot vessel to the beat of their team drummer. In our 30-minute special report Race Across...

    More >>
  • FIRST ALERT FORECAST: Storms arrive tonight, then clearing by tomorrow afternoon

    FIRST ALERT FORECAST: Storms arrive tonight, then clearing by tomorrow afternoon

    Saturday, April 21 2018 5:29 PM EDT2018-04-21 21:29:41 GMT
    Storms arrive early Sunday morningStorms arrive early Sunday morning
    Storms arrive early Sunday morningStorms arrive early Sunday morning

    Tonight, has a much better chance to see some showers and storms. Some of these storms could be strong, but the severe threat looks to be unlikely. That’s the good news for us! The bad news is that it is still raining over the weekend. The rain will last from tonight through Sunday morning. Rain chances are up to 90% tonight. By Sunday afternoon, the rain should be gone! So, it will be a wet start to the day, but it should become a sunny finish! Rain chances are still up to 70%.

    More >>

    Tonight, has a much better chance to see some showers and storms. Some of these storms could be strong, but the severe threat looks to be unlikely. That’s the good news for us! The bad news is that it is still raining over the weekend. The rain will last from tonight through Sunday morning. Rain chances are up to 90% tonight. By Sunday afternoon, the rain should be gone! So, it will be a wet start to the day, but it should become a sunny finish! Rain chances are still up to 70%.

    More >>
  • WATCH LIVE: Former first lady Barbara Bush laid to rest

    Saturday, April 21 2018 11:36 AM EDT2018-04-21 15:36:24 GMT
    (Source: KXXV)(Source: KXXV)
    (Source: KXXV)(Source: KXXV)

    The funeral service of former first lady Barbara Bush is being held at 11 a.m. today in Houston, Texas. Expected guests include former president Bill and Mrs. Bill Clinton, former president Barack and Mrs. Barack Obama and First Lady Melania Trump. Around 1,500 are expected to attend.

    More >>

    The funeral service of former first lady Barbara Bush is being held at 11 a.m. today in Houston, Texas. Expected guests include former president Bill and Mrs. Bill Clinton, former president Barack and Mrs. Barack Obama and First Lady Melania Trump. Around 1,500 are expected to attend.

    More >>
Powered by Frankly