Third Circuit throws out confession in homicide case - KPLC 7 News, Lake Charles, Louisiana

Third circuit throws out confession in homicide case

Third Circuit throws out confession in homicide case

Dennis Jerome Bartie (Source: Calcasieu Correctional Center) Dennis Jerome Bartie (Source: Calcasieu Correctional Center)
LAKE CHARLES, LA (KPLC) -

The Third Circuit Court of Appeal has ruled in favor of Dennis Bartie--finding his confession cannot be used against him at trial because detectives did not honor his right to remain silent.

 Bartie is accused of the second-degree murder of Rose Born in 1998.

Defense Attorney Todd Clemons says the law and ruling are clear.

"When someone exercises their rights to remain silent you must shut down the interview.  It doesn't say you pause for ten or fifteen seconds, you have to shut down, you have to terminate the interview.  They failed to do that and what I love about the ruling, they make it very clear, they said that this was police misconduct," said Clemons.

His co-counsel, Adam Johnson agrees.

“The Third Circuit found that this is the very type of police misconduct that was sought to be prohibited by Miranda, which is a case we're all familiar with.  Everybody knows about their Miranda warnings, their Miranda rights. The fact that they were so definitive I think sends a clear message to detectives in the future, law enforcement in the future, not to engage in the type of practices that were engaged in here,” said Johnson. 

However, Calcasieu District Attorney John DeRosier disagrees saying Bartie kept talking after saying he wanted to stop.  To truly invoke his right to remain silent, DeRosier says Bartie should have remained silent.

“When somebody says, 'I'm tired of talking, I don't want to talk anymore, and then they start talking again and they say, 'Look, I don't want to talk anymore.  Then they may initiate a conversation again.  It goes both ways. So, you got a very different set of rules that are difficult to apply when you invoke your right to remain silent and start talking again it complicates the issue," said DeRosier.

Another issue the defense raised was whether a confession was coerced because Bartie was told he could get the death penalty if he didn’t cooperate. 

"I think that he was afraid that the police were going to do exactly what they said they were going to do and that killed him if they did not cooperate with him," said Johnson.

However, DeRosier says police are permitted to use what the U.S. Supreme Court calls "strategic deception."

"Defendants don't generally walk in and tell you the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth from the outset. Very seldom does that ever happen," said DeRosier.

DeRosier says if they cannot use the confession there is other evidence.

 DeRosier says they will appeal to the State Supreme Court. The DA's office says Bartie's trial date is August 20.

The appeal court ruling can be read below.

Copyright 2018 KPLC. All rights reserved.

  • More Local NewsNewsMore>>

  • BREAKING

    Man arrested in connection with July 4 homicide on US 90, east of Lake Charles

    Man arrested in connection with July 4 homicide on US 90, east of Lake Charles

    Monday, July 16 2018 4:15 PM EDT2018-07-16 20:15:54 GMT
    Jermaine "Dutt" Washington Jr. (Source: Calcasieu Correctional Center)Jermaine "Dutt" Washington Jr. (Source: Calcasieu Correctional Center)

    A Welsh man has been arrested in connection with a July 4 homicide on US 90, near Jones Road east of Lake Charles. Jermaine “Dutt” Washington, Jr., 22, was arrested during a traffic stop on Interstate 210 Sunday. He faces counts of second-degree murder and drug possession with intent to distribute. Judge Robert Wyatt set bond at $1 million. He also has an active warrant out of Jeff Davis Parish for four drug charges, flight from an officer and careless operation. Washin...

    More >>

    A Welsh man has been arrested in connection with a July 4 homicide on US 90, near Jones Road east of Lake Charles. Jermaine “Dutt” Washington, Jr., 22, was arrested during a traffic stop on Interstate 210 Sunday. He faces counts of second-degree murder and drug possession with intent to distribute. Judge Robert Wyatt set bond at $1 million. He also has an active warrant out of Jeff Davis Parish for four drug charges, flight from an officer and careless operation. Washin...

    More >>
  • Couple accused of not feeding horses arrested for animal abuse

    Couple accused of not feeding horses arrested for animal abuse

    Monday, July 16 2018 2:33 PM EDT2018-07-16 18:33:39 GMT
    Bridget and Jerome Lavergne are accused of leaving no feed and no hay for their horses. (Source: JDPSO)Bridget and Jerome Lavergne are accused of leaving no feed and no hay for their horses. (Source: JDPSO)

    A Welsh couple is accused of not feeding their horses to the point that one horse died, according to Chief Deputy Chris Ivey, Jeff Davis Sheriff's Office spokesman. Ivey says that deputies found a horse down at a residence on Pitre Road in Welsh in March. They found no hay or feed for the animal and learned that a horse had died two weeks prior and was removed by the landowners.

    More >>

    A Welsh couple is accused of not feeding their horses to the point that one horse died, according to Chief Deputy Chris Ivey, Jeff Davis Sheriff's Office spokesman. Ivey says that deputies found a horse down at a residence on Pitre Road in Welsh in March. They found no hay or feed for the animal and learned that a horse had died two weeks prior and was removed by the landowners.

    More >>
  • CPSO: DeRidder man arrested for exposing himself at grocery store

    CPSO: DeRidder man arrested for exposing himself at grocery store

    Monday, July 16 2018 1:17 PM EDT2018-07-16 17:17:12 GMT
    Blackmon was found wearing only his underwear. (Source: CPSO)Blackmon was found wearing only his underwear. (Source: CPSO)
    Blackmon was found wearing only his underwear. (Source: CPSO)Blackmon was found wearing only his underwear. (Source: CPSO)

    CPSO deputies were investigating an obscenity complaint from a woman in the parking lot of a grocery store, says Myers. The victim was loading her groceries into her car when she noticed a man in the car next to her.  

    More >>

    CPSO deputies were investigating an obscenity complaint from a woman in the parking lot of a grocery store, says Myers. The victim was loading her groceries into her car when she noticed a man in the car next to her.  

    More >>
Powered by Frankly