La. Supreme Court throws out second-degree murder indictment in - KPLC 7 News, Lake Charles, Louisiana

BREAKING

La. Supreme Court throws out second-degree murder indictment in Woodrow Karey case

Woodrow Karey (Source: Calcasieu Parish Sheriff's Office) Woodrow Karey (Source: Calcasieu Parish Sheriff's Office)
(Source: Tabernacle of Praise Worship Center) (Source: Tabernacle of Praise Worship Center)
LAKE CHARLES, LA (KPLC) -

The Louisiana Supreme Court has thrown out a second-degree murder charge against Woodrow Karey, the man accused of shooting a pastor in a Lake Charles church in September 2013.

Karey is alleged to have killed Pastor Ronald Harris during a Friday night revival service on Sept. 27, 2013. Karey claimed at the time that Harris had raped his wife.

Click HERE to read the Supreme Court's 33-page ruling.

Karey was initially indicted on a charge of manslaughter, but the Calcasieu District Attorney's Office brought the case back to a grand jury, which indicted Karey on a second-degree murder charge.

Karey's attorneys claimed that they had provided information to the state for the initial grand jury as part of an agreement that whatever the grand jury decided would stand.

District Court Judge Clayton Davis agreed with the defense, throwing out the second-degree murder indictment. The 3rd Circuit Court of Appeal, though, reinstated the charge. The Supreme Court has now overturned the 3rd Circuit's ruling, saying it violated the agreement between the state and the defense.

The Louisiana Supreme Court ruling reads: There "was evidence in the record supporting the district court’s factual findings that the defense and the prosecution had a common goal to obtain a manslaughter indictment from the initial grand jury and that there was an 'understanding' or agreement between the parties that they would 'live with' or be bound by the conclusion of that grand jury."

The state said there was new evidence when it brought the case to a grand jury a second time. But defense attorneys don't believe that and say the District Attorney's Office succumbed to pressure from Harris' family.

"Based upon pressure from the family, they decided to renege on the deal seven-and-a-half months later," defense attorney Todd Clemons said. "They claim in pleadings, they claimed before the state Supreme Court that there was some newly discovered evidence. We're four years later, we're about to have a trial, we haven't seen any newly discovered evidence. There is no newly discovered evidence."

However, Calcasieu D.A. John DeRosier says there is new evidence, which will be revealed down the road.

"In any kind of case, particularly homicide, there's always pressure from the victim's family," DeRosier said. "That does not influence us one way or the other.  We do what we have to do.  Number two, there was significant new information contrary to what the defense may want to say that was derived from the grand jury proceeding. That's why we did not disclose it because it was grand jury information."

The state is expected to file manslaughter charges soon.

Attorney Adam Johnson said the defense plans to file for a bond reduction.

"I know we intend to file a motion for bond reduction based on the fact that this entire delay has been caused by the state not honoring its original agreement," Johnson said. "So, I think Judge Davis needs to consider a motion for bond reduction based on that fact as well.  So we'll certainly put that before him sometime next week." 

Copyright 2017 KPLC. All rights reserved.

  • More Local NewsNewsMore>>

  • Is a new bridge coming over the Contraband Bayou?

    Is a new bridge coming over the Contraband Bayou?

    Wednesday, August 23 2017 2:07 AM EDT2017-08-23 06:07:25 GMT
    (Source: Maranda Whittington/KPLC)(Source: Maranda Whittington/KPLC)

    It's not four years since residents first heard of the plan to link Nelson Road with Sallier Street and divert traffic from Lake Street.  The Louisiana Department of Transportation came back to Lake Charles Tuesday night to go over that same project.  “I came to the last meeting, and I was kind of worried that it was over with,” said resident Alain Newman.  But the Nelson Road Extension & Bridge Project is still scheduled to happen despite a four ...

    More >>

    It's not four years since residents first heard of the plan to link Nelson Road with Sallier Street and divert traffic from Lake Street.  The Louisiana Department of Transportation came back to Lake Charles Tuesday night to go over that same project.  “I came to the last meeting, and I was kind of worried that it was over with,” said resident Alain Newman.  But the Nelson Road Extension & Bridge Project is still scheduled to happen despite a four ...

    More >>
  • Deputies discuss safe boating when towing tubes, skiers or others

    Deputies discuss safe boating when towing tubes, skiers or others

    Tuesday, August 22 2017 8:48 PM EDT2017-08-23 00:48:42 GMT

    The investigation continues into the death of a child, who died while tubing. When the driver of the boat turned, the tube hit the bank flinging three boys off. Boating safety efforts can prevent many accidents.  There are things to keep in mind if towing a tube, a skier, or other recreational equipment Though fun on the water is a huge part of Southwest Louisiana culture, it can turn tragic, if boaters towing someone don't know about something called the “slingshot e...

    More >>

    The investigation continues into the death of a child, who died while tubing. When the driver of the boat turned, the tube hit the bank flinging three boys off. Boating safety efforts can prevent many accidents.  There are things to keep in mind if towing a tube, a skier, or other recreational equipment Though fun on the water is a huge part of Southwest Louisiana culture, it can turn tragic, if boaters towing someone don't know about something called the “slingshot e...

    More >>
  • Lake Charles man reunited with stolen vehicle just hours after being taken

    Lake Charles man reunited with stolen vehicle just hours after being taken

    Tuesday, August 22 2017 8:06 PM EDT2017-08-23 00:06:59 GMT
    (Source: Candy Rodriguez/KPLC)(Source: Candy Rodriguez/KPLC)

    Monday morning didn't get off to a good start for Zack Saucier. "First thing, I noticed that my truck wasn't in the spot that it's normally located," he said. "Then all of the sudden I looked over to my wife's vehicle and her two sisters and realized that they had been broken into." Saucier's Dodge Ram pickup truck was stolen overnight and the others were rummaged through, only a purse was taken from his wife's vehicle.  "I had all of sudden a huge sin...

    More >>

    Monday morning didn't get off to a good start for Zack Saucier. "First thing, I noticed that my truck wasn't in the spot that it's normally located," he said. "Then all of the sudden I looked over to my wife's vehicle and her two sisters and realized that they had been broken into." Saucier's Dodge Ram pickup truck was stolen overnight and the others were rummaged through, only a purse was taken from his wife's vehicle.  "I had all of sudden a huge sin...

    More >>
Powered by Frankly