Minaldi calls move to interdict her 'harsh' and 'overstepping' - KPLC 7 News, Lake Charles, Louisiana

Minaldi calls move to interdict her 'harsh' and 'overstepping'

SOUTHWEST LOUISIANA (KPLC) -

It's been nearly three months since U.S. District Judge Patricia Minaldi took medical leave and has been away from the bench  And more recently a petition has been filed seeking to have someone else manage Minaldi's affairs, suggesting she can't take care of herself. Minaldi is fighting the attempt.

It's a situation legal experts call bizarre - a petition to have someone else put in charge of the affairs of federal Judge Patricia Minaldi, filed by the Magistrate Judge Kathleen Kay, whom Minaldi appointed.

Kay's attorney, Tom Lorenzi, confirmed she is acting in her personal capacity as a longtime friend of Minaldi.

But Minaldi is fighting it. Her attorney Glen Vamvoras said, "The plaintiff (Kay) is seeking to permanently interdict Judge Minaldi. Minaldi feels the petition for permanent interdiction is harsh and overstepping. Hopefully, the matter can be amicably resolved."

The record in the state proceeding to have Minaldi's affairs taken over is sealed

University of Pittsburgh Law School professor Arthur Hellman is an expert in judicial ethics.

"It's certainly unfortunate and it does not promote confidence in the system when records are sealed like that. When somebody becomes a federal judge, he or she does give up, to some degree, privacy an ordinary citizen would have," he said.

Legal experts say it's an extremely unusual situation.

"I can't remember any episode where essentially you have two federal judges, because a magistrate judge is a federal judge, fighting it out in a state court," said Hellman.

Loyola Law Professor Dane Ciolino agrees.

"To have a petitioner for interdiction being a United States Magistrate Judge who essentially works for the district judge, makes it just a very unusual matter. Because usually interdiction petitions are filed by a family member, usually children or spouses," he said.

Minaldi has served on the bench since 2003, but pleaded guilty to a drunk driving charge in 2014.  Even if the judge in the interdiction finds against Minaldi, the experts say it would have no immediate effect on her position on the bench, since federal judge's are appointed for life.

"If she meets the criteria for interdiction she would as a practical matter she would not be fit to service as a United States district judge and I say that because the criteria for interdiction in Louisiana are that the person subject to the interdiction is unable consistently to make reasoned decisions about the care of themselves or their property,"said Ciolino.

Federal judges only leave the bench by impeachment or by retiring. Minaldi has been on medical leave since January. 

State District Judge Ron Ware is overseeing the case about whether Minaldi needs someone to oversee her personal affairs.   Because the record is sealed, no word as to when there may be a hearing on the interdiction petition.

Copyright 2017 KPLC All rights reserved

  • More Local NewsNewsMore>>

  • WATCH LIVE at 1:15 p.m.: VP Mike Pence speaks in Baton Rouge

    WATCH LIVE at 1:15 p.m.: VP Mike Pence speaks in Baton Rouge

    Wednesday, May 24 2017 1:37 PM EDT2017-05-24 17:37:11 GMT
    (Source: Wikipedia)(Source: Wikipedia)

    Vice President Mike Pence is set to arrive around 11:40 a.m. in Baton Rouge Wednesday. Pence is scheduled to meet with business leaders around the Baton Rouge area. 

    More >>

    Vice President Mike Pence is set to arrive around 11:40 a.m. in Baton Rouge Wednesday. Pence is scheduled to meet with business leaders around the Baton Rouge area. 

    More >>
  • Legal Corner: Do I really need a will in Louisiana?

    Legal Corner: Do I really need a will in Louisiana?

    Wednesday, May 24 2017 12:28 PM EDT2017-05-24 16:28:48 GMT
    Source: KPLCSource: KPLC
    Submit your question to news@kplctv.com. Question: Do I really need a will in Louisiana? What is the downside to not having one? First, it is important to differentiate between a living will and a last will and testament. A living will is effective only when a person becomes terminally ill or has an irreversible condition. A traditional or “last will” is not effective until the testator – the author of the will – passes away. The two types of traditional will...More >>
    Submit your question to news@kplctv.com. Question: Do I really need a will in Louisiana? What is the downside to not having one? First, it is important to differentiate between a living will and a last will and testament. A living will is effective only when a person becomes terminally ill or has an irreversible condition. A traditional or “last will” is not effective until the testator – the author of the will – passes away. The two types of traditional will...More >>
  • breaking

    LCPD investigating shooting death on Fournet Street

    LCPD investigating shooting death on Fournet Street

    Wednesday, May 24 2017 11:56 AM EDT2017-05-24 15:56:59 GMT
    (Source: Antoine Aaron / KPLC)(Source: Antoine Aaron / KPLC)

    A precautionary lockdown is in place at Ralph Wilson Elementary School on Opelousas street due to an incident with the Lake Charles Police Department in the area. All students and faculty are safe. KPLC is working on gathering more details. Copyright 2017 KPLC. All rights reserved.

    More >>

    A precautionary lockdown is in place at Ralph Wilson Elementary School on Opelousas street due to an incident with the Lake Charles Police Department in the area. All students and faculty are safe. KPLC is working on gathering more details. Copyright 2017 KPLC. All rights reserved.

    More >>
Powered by Frankly