Louisiana ban on same sex marriages upheld in federal court - KPLC 7 News, Lake Charles, Louisiana

Louisiana ban on same sex marriages upheld in federal court

NEW ORLEANS, LA (WAFB) - After a cascade of federal courts across the country striking down same sex marriage bans, Federal Judge Martin Feldman made a different stand from his New Orleans courtroom, upholding Louisiana's ban on gay marriage and determining that the state does not have to recognize same sex marriages legally obtained in other states. 

"He wanted, I think, to stop it because he has anticipation that the Supreme Court will stop it,” said LSU Law professor Paul Baier. 

Both praises for the ruling and critiques rolled in after it was handed down just before noon Tuesday. 

"This ruling confirms that the people of Louisiana - not the federal courts - have the constitutional right to decide how marriage is defined in this state," said president of the Louisiana Family Forum Gene Mills. 

Meanwhile, gay rights advocates express frustration and even anger. 

"Folks were hanging on this ruling so that they could get married where their homes are and where their families live are obviously distraught because this is yet another delay," said Matt Patterson of the 

Louisiana Equality Forum. 

Feldman's ruling expressed the definition of marriage should be left up to the state and the democratic process, not judges.  

"There's always contention in how far the court can go in overruling a democratically elected judgments," said Baier. 

One of the several arguments against the ban stemmed from a 1967 case in Virginia dealing with the issue of interracial marriage. In Loving v. Virginia the Supreme Court ruled that banning interracial marriage was unconstitutional because it discriminated against race and thus violated the 14th Amendment.  

Plaintiffs in this case argued that Louisiana's ban was also unconstitutional because it discriminates against gender, and that the ruling in Loving could be applied here. 

However, Feldman rejected that argument, saying that the Louisiana laws do not discriminate against gender. Baier, is a long time constitutional law professor at LSU, disagrees.

"I think he misses the idea that the equal protection clause is not race based. The Supreme Court has said that he equal protection clause gives everyone equality," said Baier. 

Other arguments against the ban included violation of the First Amendment and Due Process, all of which Feldmen rejected. 

The ruling however, is far from settled.  There are plans to appeal and many point to the supreme court for the final decision, something even Feldman acknowledges himself, saying in his ruling "clearly, many other courts will have an opportunity to take up the issue of same-sex marriage… The decision of this court is but on studied decision among many.”

"You settle the mess when you reach the Supreme Court and five judges will vote to sustain or reject these prohibitions," said Baier. 

Copyright 2014 WAFB. All rights reserved.


  • More Local NewsNewsMore>>

  • FIRST ALERT FORECAST: Warm temperatures continue, with pop up showers possible; A big cool down coming later in the week

    FIRST ALERT FORECAST: Warm temperatures continue, with pop up showers possible; A big cool down coming later in the week

    Saturday, September 23 2017 6:11 PM EDT2017-09-23 22:11:18 GMT
    Few showers possible tomorrowFew showers possible tomorrow

    By tonight, rain chances will stay low. We will have mostly clear skies late. Low temperatures will be in the low 70s. It will also feel muggy overnight, thanks to the humidity. There could be some areas of patchy fog in the early morning hours. Sunday will be another day with partly cloudy skies with very few showers popping up in the afternoon. Rain chances will remain at 20%, so that does not mean that we will not see any rain, just not very likely. Highs will be in the upper 80s.

    More >>

    By tonight, rain chances will stay low. We will have mostly clear skies late. Low temperatures will be in the low 70s. It will also feel muggy overnight, thanks to the humidity. There could be some areas of patchy fog in the early morning hours. Sunday will be another day with partly cloudy skies with very few showers popping up in the afternoon. Rain chances will remain at 20%, so that does not mean that we will not see any rain, just not very likely. Highs will be in the upper 80s.

    More >>
  • Avoid Country Club Road/Canal Street due to structure fire

    Avoid Country Club Road/Canal Street due to structure fire

    Saturday, September 23 2017 6:01 PM EDT2017-09-23 22:01:00 GMT
    (Source: KPLC)(Source: KPLC)

    The Lake Charles Police Department is urging drivers to avoid the intersection of Country Club Road and Canal Street due to a structure fire in the area.

    Country Club Road southbound is closed off near the fire, according to LCPD.

    More >>

    The Lake Charles Police Department is urging drivers to avoid the intersection of Country Club Road and Canal Street due to a structure fire in the area.

    Country Club Road southbound is closed off near the fire, according to LCPD.

    More >>
  • Hodges Gardens State Park officially closing Oct. 1

    Hodges Gardens State Park officially closing Oct. 1

    Saturday, September 23 2017 12:18 PM EDT2017-09-23 16:18:26 GMT
    (Source: Maranda Whittington/KPLC)(Source: Maranda Whittington/KPLC)

    Hodges Gardens. It's one of the most beautiful spots in Louisiana, but in just days visitors will no longer be able to see it.  It's almost time.  Time for something good to come to an end.  Chris Nolen is sorting and packing up items from Hodges Gardens State Park.  "What are you going to do with magnets that say Hodges Gardens State Park when there's no state park," said Nolen.  That's right Hodges Gardens will officially be closing ...

    More >>

    Hodges Gardens. It's one of the most beautiful spots in Louisiana, but in just days visitors will no longer be able to see it.  It's almost time.  Time for something good to come to an end.  Chris Nolen is sorting and packing up items from Hodges Gardens State Park.  "What are you going to do with magnets that say Hodges Gardens State Park when there's no state park," said Nolen.  That's right Hodges Gardens will officially be closing ...

    More >>
Powered by Frankly