Supreme Court dismisses Boyer murder conviction appeal - KPLC 7 News, Lake Charles, Louisiana

Supreme Court dismisses Boyer murder conviction appeal

LAKE CHARLES, LA (KPLC) -

The Calcasieu District Attorney's Office is claiming a victory after the U.S. Supreme Court dismissed an appeal from a Louisiana man who claimed that most of his seven-year delay between his arrest and murder trial was the result of inadequate funding for paying his court appointed defense attorneys in death penalty cases.

The court ruled in a 5-4 vote Monday to dismiss the appeal of Jonathan Boyer, who eventually was convicted and sentenced to life in the second-degree murder of Bradlee Marsh.

Investigators say Boyer killed Marsh in 2002. The case would not go to trial until 2009.

Boyer's appeal was heard before the Supreme Court in January. Arguing the case for state was Calcasieu Assistant District Attorney Carla Sigler. Sigler told the high court in fact it was Boyer's own attorneys who caused the delay with numerous continuances.

Calcasieu District Attorney John DeRosier is pleased with the outcome.  

"Basically, the judgement held that the time delays that resulted in approximately seven years in date of offense and date of trial were the result of issues raised by the defense and continued by defense on numerous occasions," said DeRosier.

The Supreme Court stated other delays - like Hurricane Rita - were out of anyone's control.

First Assistant District Attorney Cynthia Killingsworth prosecuted the case and said she was shocked it went all the way to the Supreme Court.

"I was quite surprised. I didn't think we were going to have a problem with anything in regards to time ... And the Supreme Court agreed, too, because they ruled in favor of the state this time as well," said Killingsworth.

Boyer was originally charged with first-degree murder - meaning he could have received the death penalty had he been convicted on that charge. The Calcasieu District Attorney's Office dropped the charge to second-degree murder to move the case to trial.  

The Supreme Court also noted: If the defense had not sought and obtained continuances, the trial might well have commenced at a much earlier date and might have reached a conclusion far less favorable to the defense.

"This was a big decision in favor of prosecutors all over the country because this as the court eluded to in this case - this granting of this writ - in other words, accepting of this case by the United States Supreme Court, was improvident. That means had we known all the facts in the case, we wouldn't have accepted this to begin with," explained DeRosier.

You may remember the case also received a lot of national attention because Justice Clarence Thomas broke his seven-year silence from the bench during the questioning phase when he made a joke in the proceedings.

Copyright 2013 KPLC. All rights reserved. The Associated Press contributed to this report.

  • More Local NewsNewsMore>>

  • Law enforcement talk about recent school threats

    Tuesday, February 20 2018 10:32 PM EST2018-02-21 03:32:42 GMT
    (Source: Maranda Whittington/KPLC)(Source: Maranda Whittington/KPLC)
    Tension across Louisiana with a number of school threats reported in the wake of the Florida school shooting.  That includes DeRidder where the Beauregard Parish Sheriff's Office confirms it detained a juvenile Monday over threats against DeRidder High School.  In Jeff Davis Parish, police searched Welsh High School Tuesday after reports of a gun on campus. No gun was found.  In Oakdale, a middle school student was taken into custody for allegedly making, and threats...More >>
    Tension across Louisiana with a number of school threats reported in the wake of the Florida school shooting.  That includes DeRidder where the Beauregard Parish Sheriff's Office confirms it detained a juvenile Monday over threats against DeRidder High School.  In Jeff Davis Parish, police searched Welsh High School Tuesday after reports of a gun on campus. No gun was found.  In Oakdale, a middle school student was taken into custody for allegedly making, and threats...More >>
  • Daniel Kight found guilty of second degree murder

    Daniel Kight found guilty of second degree murder

    Tuesday, February 20 2018 8:26 PM EST2018-02-21 01:26:22 GMT
    Daniel Kight. (Source: Vinton Police Department)Daniel Kight. (Source: Vinton Police Department)

    Daniel Kight was found guilty of second degree murder today during his murder trial.  Kight pleaded not guilty due to reason of insanity after gruesomely murdering David Scasino. Prosecutors say Scasino was stabbed at least fifty times and his body was mutilated. After Kight visited a state appointed a psychologist, Judge Robert Wyatt had to base the decision on whether Kight knew right from wrong at the time of the offense.  Kight's sentencing is set at 1:30 p.m. on

    More >>

    Daniel Kight was found guilty of second degree murder today during his murder trial.  Kight pleaded not guilty due to reason of insanity after gruesomely murdering David Scasino. Prosecutors say Scasino was stabbed at least fifty times and his body was mutilated. After Kight visited a state appointed a psychologist, Judge Robert Wyatt had to base the decision on whether Kight knew right from wrong at the time of the offense.  Kight's sentencing is set at 1:30 p.m. on

    More >>
  • The Louisiana Partnership for Children and Families to host stakeholders meeting

    The Louisiana Partnership for Children and Families to host stakeholders meeting

    The Louisiana Partnership for Children and Families to host stakeholders meeting

    Tuesday, February 20 2018 7:53 PM EST2018-02-21 00:53:15 GMT
    Image courtesy of The Louisiana Partnership for Children and FamiliesImage courtesy of The Louisiana Partnership for Children and Families

               The Louisiana Partnership for Children and Families, the only statewide organization connecting child-serving organizations together for better outcomes for children, is hosting a series of regional meetings throughout the state to bring together stakeholders and discuss important issues facing children.                     Connecting the Dots for Children is a two-hour event featuring inf...

    More >>

               The Louisiana Partnership for Children and Families, the only statewide organization connecting child-serving organizations together for better outcomes for children, is hosting a series of regional meetings throughout the state to bring together stakeholders and discuss important issues facing children.                     Connecting the Dots for Children is a two-hour event featuring inf...

    More >>
Powered by Frankly