Davis & Saltzman Trial: defense reveals mystery document - KPLC 7 News, Lake Charles, Louisiana

Davis & Saltzman Trial: defense reveals mystery document

LAKE CHARLES, LA (KPLC) -

Defense attorneys produced a DOTD record that says the Black Bayou Pontoon bridge was open for barge traffic between 3:31 p.m. and 3:47 p.m. and that, therefore, the timetable of the suspect's involvement in Brian Davis's murder won't stand.

Anyone who drives Big Lake road to Cameron Parish knows they may get hung up at the bridge which is closed to cars when the structure is open so that barge traffic can pass. Well the defense says state DOTD records show that Robyn Davis and Sissy Saltzman could not have followed the timeline the state put forth because the closure of the bridge for that sixteen minutes made their involvement impossible.

The defense confronted FBI cell phone expert William Shute with that-- but Shute says if the record is right it just means the Robyn and Brian Davis got to the bridge before it was closed to car traffic. Brian Davis was murdered at the end of Wagon Wheel off Big Lake Road-- and the State and FBI expert say cell phone records show Robyn Davis and Sissy Saltzman were not where they said they were.

The jury saw Shute's power point presentation mapping out where he says the women were the day Brian was murdered and the day before.

Shute uses cell detail records to plot locations. His analysis basically shows that the women were in the area where Brian was murdered-- even though that contradicts their statements to investigators.

However the defense has put on an expert who disputes Shute's methods and basically says his report is biased and likely reached false conclusions. The defense seeks to raise doubts in the jurors minds about the accuracy and reliability of Shute's findings and the state's case.

Shute's analysis also suggests the women may have been surveying the area of the murder scene the day before the killing, perhaps planning a route to and from the crime scene.

The state rested its case after Shute testified and the defense began putting on its witnesses.  The evidence part of the trial is expected to conclude Wednesday and closing arguments are likely Thursday.

Theresa Schmidt will be in court providing updates through the day. To follow the Davis and Saltzman live blog [CLICK HERE].

Copyright 2012 KPLC. All rights reserved.

  • More Local NewsNewsMore>>

  • FIRST ALERT FORECAST: Slight cool down arrives this weekend, warm and humid until then

    FIRST ALERT FORECAST: Slight cool down arrives this weekend, warm and humid until then

    Tuesday, September 26 2017 4:49 PM EDT2017-09-26 20:49:03 GMT
    Cold front slowly moving toward SWLACold front slowly moving toward SWLA

    No major changes are expected with the forecast for the next few days.  And that means the heat and humidity will remain in place along with a slight chance of rain.  A cold front will arrive later this week and should bring a slight drop in humidity just in time for the weekend.  Temperatures will be warm and humid overnight into Wednesday morning with lows ranging from the mid 60s north of I-10 to the mid 70s at the coast.

    More >>

    No major changes are expected with the forecast for the next few days.  And that means the heat and humidity will remain in place along with a slight chance of rain.  A cold front will arrive later this week and should bring a slight drop in humidity just in time for the weekend.  Temperatures will be warm and humid overnight into Wednesday morning with lows ranging from the mid 60s north of I-10 to the mid 70s at the coast.

    More >>
  • LIVE UPDATES: Defense rests in Stacy Johnson's first-degree murder trial

    LIVE UPDATES: Defense rests in Stacy Johnson's first-degree murder trial

    Tuesday, September 26 2017 1:38 PM EDT2017-09-26 17:38:02 GMT
    Stacy Johnson Jr. (Source: Calcasieu Correctional Center)Stacy Johnson Jr. (Source: Calcasieu Correctional Center)
    The defense has rested in Stacy Johnson's first-degree murder trial. Johnson is accused of murdering Robert Colston Sr.  Johnson was 16 at the time the 79-year-old Colston died. When court resumes at 1 p.m., the court is expected to discuss with the defendant whether he understands his right to testify. KPLC's Theresa Schmidt is in the courtroom. Follow her HERE. A juvenile relative of Stacy Johnson took the stand today as the defense put on its case. The witness dispute...More >>
    The defense has rested in Stacy Johnson's first-degree murder trial. Johnson is accused of murdering Robert Colston Sr.  Johnson was 16 at the time the 79-year-old Colston died. When court resumes at 1 p.m., the court is expected to discuss with the defendant whether he understands his right to testify. KPLC's Theresa Schmidt is in the courtroom. Follow her HERE. A juvenile relative of Stacy Johnson took the stand today as the defense put on its case. The witness dispute...More >>
  • BREAKING

    Authorities say couple arrested after malnourished 5-year-old girl brought to hospital with lacerated kidney, bruises and sores

    Authorities say couple arrested after malnourished 5-year-old girl brought to hospital with lacerated kidney, bruises and sores

    Tuesday, September 26 2017 12:44 PM EDT2017-09-26 16:44:05 GMT
    (Source: Calcasieu Parish Sheriff's Office)(Source: Calcasieu Parish Sheriff's Office)
    A Vinton couple is under arrest after a malnourished child brought to a hospital was found to have a lacerated kidney and several sores, bruises and rashes, authorities said. Detectives found the home in which the 5-year-old girl lived to be unkempt, with animal urine and feces throughout the residence, said Cmdr. James McGee, Calcasieu Parish Sheriff's Office spokesman. Three other children were living in the home - a 9-year-old, a 7-year-old and a 3-year-old. The ch...More >>
    A Vinton couple is under arrest after a malnourished child brought to a hospital was found to have a lacerated kidney and several sores, bruises and rashes, authorities said. Detectives found the home in which the 5-year-old girl lived to be unkempt, with animal urine and feces throughout the residence, said Cmdr. James McGee, Calcasieu Parish Sheriff's Office spokesman. Three other children were living in the home - a 9-year-old, a 7-year-old and a 3-year-old. The ch...More >>
Powered by Frankly